1995 — First year — Record 2-5

Beat Taylor University in the first ever game—32-24

 

1996 — Record 4-6

First win over nationally ranked team—31-23 over Olivet Nazarene

1997 — Record 4-6

1998 —  Record 11-3

Wins over nationally ranked Campbellsville University, Malone College, and Taylor University.

First NAIA Play-off appearance

First Round win vs. Benedictine College— 33-28

Quarterfinal win vs. Georgetown College— 37-23

Final NAIA Ranking - 3rd

 

1999 — Record 6-4

Final NAIA Ranking - 26th

 

2000 — Record 6-5

Wins over nationally ranked Taylor University, St. Ambrose University, and Geneva College.
Final NAIA Ranking - 28th

 

2001 — Record 8-3

Mid-States Football Association Mideast Conference Champions
Wins over nationally ranked St. Ambrose University, Geneva College, and the University of St. Francis-IN.
NAIA Play-offs - First Round
Final NAIA Ranking - 11th

 

2002__ Record 6-3
          2nd place in the Mid-States Mideast Conference
          Final NAIA rank 21st
          Win over nationally ranked Walsh University

8 year record — 46-35

Play-off record — 2-2